The Oval is the lawn at the west edge of the Town Park Core Area, beside the Warming Hut and Washstand building that opened in June 2025. In summer it fills with picnics, birthdays, quinceañeras and celebrations of life, according to one resident's written comment to the Parks & Recreation Commission. In winter, once it is cold enough, it becomes one of Telluride's two outdoor ice rinks. The other is at the volleyball courts.
This summer the Parks & Recreation Commission recommended keeping the grass, and Town staff are now revising the design along those lines. Most of the debate was about green space and pickleball noise. The concrete surface the Commission set aside was the part of the project meant to give Telluride a better base for making ice. If the grass plan holds, the Oval rink will keep depending on the weather, as it always has.
The Concrete Pad Was Also the Ice Plan
The Oval Improvements Project is the third phase of the Core Area work laid out in the 2020 Town Parks Master Plan. The skatepark came first, then the Warming Hut and Washstand. The town's staff memo lists four goals for the project, and the third is "improved surface for ice making during winter season."
The approved design met that goal with an 85-by-150-foot concrete slab. In summer it would hold planters, seating and a wall ball court. In winter it would be the ice rink. The design had already cleared its reviews. The Parks & Recreation Commission approved schematics in 2021, HARC issued a Certificate of Appropriateness, and construction documents and permitting were finished.
As public opposition grew, staff came back with two alternatives for the Commission's July 29 work session. The three options split the Oval this way:
| Option | Concrete | Grass | Winter ice surface |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current design | 14,215 sq ft, 59% | 9,742 sq ft, 41% | 85 x 150 ft concrete rink |
| Alternate Concept #1 | 9,125 sq ft, 38% | 14,832 sq ft, 62% | Reduced 85 x 90 ft rink |
| Alternate Concept #2 | 1,300 sq ft, 5% | 22,657 sq ft, 95% | No concrete rink surface |
Alternate #2 drops the concrete rink and the east-side plaza. It enlarges the existing basketball court to 50 by 85 feet in its current spot. None of the three options adds lighting beyond the streetlights already around the Oval.
How the Grass Won the Commission on July 29
The Telluride Times covered the work session at Rebekah Hall. It reported that petitions against paving the Oval had collected 454 signatures and that 55 written comments came in. Much of the opposition was about pickleball, and Commission chair Tommy Thacher told the room that pickleball concerns had "been heard loud and clear."
The straw poll of people attending was lopsided. The Town's project page records 69 votes for Alternate #2, 10 for Alternate #1 and none for the original design. The commissioners were much closer. They voted 4–3 to recommend Alternate #2 to staff.
Nancy Landau helped lead the petition drive. She described the recommended plan to the Times in words that define what winter on the Oval would look like:
"That plan would keep the oval green, improve and enlarge the existing basketball court to regulation high school dimensions and allow for skating to continue on the oval when we have favorable winter weather."
The key phrase is "favorable winter weather." Skating would stay, with no slab under it. Brian Wolahan backed Alternate #2 in public comment and added, "If we can use that in the winter, either as a hockey rink or for public skating, it would be nice."
Hockey families were not united behind the concrete either. One written comment in the Commission packet came from a parent whose son plays on the outdoor rink. The parent wrote that the family remained opposed to paving even though outdoor rink users were listed as the people who would benefit.
Some speakers wanted a court. Dylan Cantor coaches the Telluride High School boys' basketball team, and he favored Alternate #1. He told the meeting that grass "requires a lot of irrigation" and that "our region is in severe drought." KOTO's newscast from the meeting also quoted Dylan Brooks, who supported a proper basketball court and argued that basketball players had been underrepresented in the discussion.
The Construction Fence Comes First
Even without the slab, the Oval has had crews on it this fall. Phase 1 runs September 23 through December 18, 2026, and the Town says it is going ahead separately from the surfacing question. The work includes a new Warner Field outfield fence with safety netting, an underground drainage pipe across the north side of the Oval, and replacement streetlights with new electrical infrastructure. The Town budgeted $800,000 for this phase in 2026.
The work also changes how the park functions. A new center-field gate is meant to move people out of Town Park more easily after big events. The netting is meant to protect people nearby during adult softball games. The Town says that could open up the Core Area on softball evenings from mid-May through late July. Until the December 18 end date, the Town's project page warns of trail detours, noise and construction traffic in the western part of the park.
The outdoor rinks are weather-dependent and typically open in December. Last winter, the Town Manager's December 16, 2025 report described both outdoor rinks, at the volleyball courts and the Core Area Oval, as "under construction" and closed to the public. That is the town's term for ice being built before it opens. The same report said the Warming Hut and main restrooms would stay closed until the outdoor rink opened for the season. A single restroom on the west side of the building stayed open daily from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. By the March 17, 2026 report, all ice rinks were closed for the season.
Where the Ice Runs on a Calendar
If the Oval depends on cold weather, Hanley Ice Rink is the reliable option. It is the indoor rink in the Town Park Pavilion. In June, the Parks & Recreation Commission approved a 2026–27 season of October 7, 2026 through March 3, 2027. The draft schedule follows last winter's pattern. Weekday public skating is generally 10:15 to 11:45 a.m. and 1:45 to 3:15 p.m. Saturday public skating is mainly 10:15 to 11:45 a.m. and can move around paid rentals. The schedule also says holiday and weekend hours can open later or close earlier. The live schedule on the Town's site is the one to check.
The same packet shows what it costs to run indoor ice. The proposed hourly ice cost for 2026–27 is $92.12, up $3.27 or 3.7 percent from 2025–26. The Town describes public skating and youth drop-in fees as heavily subsidized.
Skating on the Town Park outdoor ice is free. The Telluride Nordic Center shares the Pavilion with Hanley and rents skates, Nordic skis, sleds and snowshoes. In season its rental hours are daily from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., and its page says regular hours resume in November. When the outdoor ice isn't ready, the snow next to it usually is. Town Park has about three kilometers of groomed Nordic trails, with dog access marked on the trail map. Just east, the Valley Floor has about 15 kilometers of Nordic terrain where dogs are not allowed. Last December, the Town reported the Town Park trails open and groomed daily.
What Town Council Still Decides
The July vote was a recommendation, and Town Council still has to act. The Town's project page was last updated October 22. It says staff and the design team are revising the Oval design to match Alternate #2 for another Commission review. An updated cost estimate will go to Council during the budget process, and the Phase 2 construction is on hold until design review and budget approval are done. The $1,334,300 that had been set aside for Phase 2 in 2027 was priced for the paved design. The project page now lists the Phase 2 budget as "to be updated."
Under the revised plan, the 2027 work would be grading, drainage, irrigation and new sod for the grass Oval, plus a larger basketball court on the Oval's south side. The staff memo says a management plan comes before any construction. It would set the allowed uses, restrictions, scheduling and steps to limit impacts, and it would address neighborhood concerns such as noise. At the July meeting, Parks and Recreation Director Stephanie Jaquet told the Times, "We have not signed any construction contracts. Moving forward on any of that depends on the direction provided."
That management plan will set how the Oval is used in every season. Until then, skating there this winter starts when the cold weather allows it.
If you own or are considering a home within walking distance of Town Park, the decisions being made about the Core Area affect daily life on those blocks. O'Neill Stetina Group follows these projects closely as part of our work in Telluride. If you'd like to talk through what this means for a specific property, schedule a private consultation.